14th April 1996
| Final | Rotherham United | 2-1 | Shrewsbury Town |
12th March 1996
| Southern Section Final 2nd Leg | Bristol Rovers | 0-1 | Shrewsbury Town |
| Northern Section Final 2nd Leg | Carlisle United | 0-2 | Rotherham United |
5th March 1996
| Northern Section Final 1st Leg | Rotherham United | 2-0 | Carlisle United |
| Southern Section Final 1st Leg | Shrewsbury Town | 1-1 | Bristol Rovers |
13th February 1996
| Southern Section Semi-Final | Peterborough United | 0-1 | Bristol Rovers |
| Northern Section Semi-Final | Rotherham United | 4-1 |
31st January 1996
| Southern Section Semi-Final | Shrewsbury Town | 4-1 |
30th January 1996
| Northern Section Semi-Final | Carlisle United | 1-0 |
9th January 1996
| Northern Section Quarter-Final | 1-0 | Notts. County |
| Southern Section Quarter-Final | Shrewsbury Town | 4-2 | Brighton & Hove Albion |
| Southern Section Quarter-Final | 1-0 | Northampton Town |
| Southern Section Quarter-Final | Fulham | 1-2 | Bristol Rovers |
| Northern Section Quarter-Final | Rotherham United | 3-1 | Lincoln City |
| Northern Section Quarter-Final | Blackpool | 0-1 |
| Southern Section Quarter-Final | Peterborough United | 3-2 | Colchester United |
6th January 1996
| Northern Section Quarter-Final | Carlisle United | 5-0 | Burnley |
29th November 1995
| Southern Section 1st Round | 0-1 |
| Northern Section 1st Round | 0-1 | Burnley |
28th November 1995
| Southern Section 1st Round | Walsall | 1-2 | Brighton & Hove Albion |
| Northern Section 1st Round | 1-2 | Carlisle United |
| Northern Section 1st Round | Scunthorpe United | 0-3 |
| Northern Section 1st Round | Rotherham United | 0-0 | Wigan Athletic |
| Northern Section 1st Round | Hull City | 1-2 | Blackpool |
| Northern Section 1st Round | Lincoln City | 2-1 | Preston North End |
| Northern Section 1st Round | 2-1 |
| Southern Section 1st Round | Brentford | 0-1 | Fulham |
| Southern Section 1st Round | Bristol Rovers | 2-1 | AFC Bournemouth |
| Southern Section 1st Round | Oxford United | 1-2 | Colchester United |
| Southern Section 1st Round | Cardiff City | 1-2 | Northampton Town |
| Southern Section 1st Round | Peterborough United | 1-0 | Swansea City |
| Southern Section 1st Round | Shrewsbury Town | 0-0 | Bristol City |
27th November 1995
| Northern Section 1st Round | 1-3 | Notts. County |
14th November 1995
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Five | 0-0 | Wigan Athletic |
8th November 1995
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Eight | 2-0 | Colchester United |
7th November 1995
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group One | 3-2 | Blackpool |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Two | Burnley | 1-1 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Three | Notts. County | 1-0 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Four | 0-1 | Lincoln City |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Seven | Preston North End | 2-1 |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group One | Leyton Orient | 1-3 | Shrewsbury Town |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Two | 2-2 |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Three | Northampton Town | 1-0 | Plymouth Argyle |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Four | Walsall | 5-0 | Wycombe Wanderers |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Eight | Carlisle United | 1-1 |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Seven | 2-3 | Oxford United |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Five | Exeter City | 0-2 | AFC Bournemouth |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Six | Bristol Rovers | 3-0 | Cambridge United |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Six | 1-0 | Mansfield Town |
24th October 1995
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Four | 5-2 |
17th October 1995
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Two | Cardiff City | 3-2 |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group One | Swansea City | 0-0 | Leyton Orient |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Eight | Bradford City | 1-1 | Carlisle United |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Seven | Hull City | 1-0 | Preston North End |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Six | 1-0 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Five | Scunthorpe United | 4-0 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Three | 2-1 | Notts. County |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Two | Rotherham United | 1-1 | Burnley |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Six | Brighton & Hove Albion | 0-2 | Bristol Rovers |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group One | 8-0 |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Seven | Bristol City | 2-0 |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Five | Brentford | 1-1 | Exeter City |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Eight | 1-1 |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Four | Fulham | 2-5 | Walsall |
16th October 1995
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Three | Peterborough United | 0-0 | Northampton Town |
10th October 1995
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Four | Wycombe Wanderers | 1-1 | Fulham |
27th September 1995
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Five | AFC Bournemouth | 0-1 | Brentford |
26th September 1995
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Three | Plymouth Argyle | 0-3 | Peterborough United |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Two | 3-3 | Cardiff City |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group One | Shrewsbury Town | 1-1 | Swansea City |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group One | Blackpool | 1-0 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Seven | 0-2 | Hull City |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Six | Mansfield Town | 2-2 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Five | Wigan Athletic | 1-1 | Scunthorpe United |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Four | Lincoln City | 4-3 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Three | 1-1 |
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Two | 0-1 | Rotherham United |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Six | Cambridge United | 1-4 | Brighton & Hove Albion |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Seven | Oxford United | 3-0 | Bristol City |
| Southern Section Preliminary Round Group Eight | Colchester United | 5-2 |
25th September 1995
| Northern Section Preliminary Round Group Eight | 1-1 | Bradford City |